Driver Buys Coffee For Kind Car Behind Them to Pay It Forward, But There’s a Problem

A simple act of generosity at a Tim Hortons drive-thru took an unexpected turn when a driver, attempting to show appreciation, ended up buying coffee for the wrong person.

The story, shared by Reddit user RedditGarboDisposal, began when their usual Tim Hortons was temporarily closed for maintenance, forcing commuters into an already congested alternate location.

Chaotic Line

The drive-thru line was chaotic, with two separate entrances, making it difficult for cars to merge fairly.

After waiting with their turn signal on, the driver was finally let in by a black Honda. Wanting to return the favor, they decided to cover the Honda’s order at the window.

But as they drove off, they realized the next car in line was not the Honda—it was a blue Hyundai.

“Turns out they let someone else in after me too,” the original poster (OP) wrote, “So someone got two freebies today!”

Despite the mix-up, the driver remained in good spirits, hoping that the unintended recipient would continue the goodwill.

The Power of Paying It Forward

This drive-thru mix-up is just one example of how small acts of generosity can take on a life of their own.

In a similar event reported by Newsweek, a McDonald’s in Florida experienced a “pay-it-forward” chain that lasted more than 900 orders. The phenomenon—where one customer pays for the next, inspiring a ripple effect—has been observed at various fast-food chains across North America.

According to behavioral researchers, acts of generosity trigger positive emotions not only in recipients, but also in those who perform them. The motivation is often a combination of gratitude, empathy and the psychological reward of knowing they’ve made someone’s day just a little better.

One Reddit user in the Tim Hortons thread pointed out that the OP hadn’t actually messed up at all:

“Imagine how happily surprised that random stranger will be. You did a good deed because someone did a good deed for you.

“Doesn’t matter if it wasn’t the same person. I don’t think you [messed up] at all. You are a nice and kind person.”

‘Things are looking up!’

Generosity doesn’t always go according to plan, but its impact is undeniable. According to BetterHelp, helping others leads to greater emotional well-being, reinforcing a sense of community and human connection.

Research suggests that even witnessing a good deed—whether in real life or through stories—can inspire people to pass on kindness in their own way.

Something as small as covering a coffee order can create a ripple effect that extends beyond the initial moment.

A Redditor imagined how the recipient of the surprise coffee in the Hyundai may have reacted: “Whoa, the wind is at my back today!

“Some friendly person let me cut the line, and not only did I not have to wait for my coffee, but some King bought it for me. Things are looking up!”

Newsweek has contacted RedditGarboDisposal for comment via Reddit.

Newsweek‘s “What Should I Do?” offers expert advice to readers. If you have a personal dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice on relationships, family, friends, money and work, and your story could be featured on WSID at Newsweek.

To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, click here.