Fury at What MIL Does at Restaurant During Son’s Birthday Dinner: ‘Disrespectful’

A tense family dispute escalated at a birthday dinner when a woman’s mother-in-law (MIL) attempted to take her baby from her arms without speaking to her.

The woman, posting under the username One-Pineapple6919, described on Reddit how tensions had been growing between her and her husband’s family of seven after she and her husband stopped financially supporting his mother.

‘Upset the whole house’

The couple, who married and had a child within a year and a half of their relationship, had been paying her bills to help her get on her feet. However, with their baby’s arrival, they decided their finances needed to be focused on their child’s future.

The decision was not well received by the husband’s family.

“This upset the whole house and everybody started to tell us how they really felt—well, not even us, just me,” the original poster (OP) told Redditors this week.

She said that her in-laws accused her of “corrupting” her husband and taking him away from them, referring to him as their, “Leader and support.”

The situation reached a breaking point during her husband’s birthday dinner, where she said she was mostly ignored by his family. Toward the end of the evening, her MIL attempted to take her baby from her arms without acknowledging her.

“I just pushed her hands away and she starts yelling, ‘I can’t take my grandbaby?’ in the middle of the restaurant,” the OP wrote.

“Now they’re talking about how I ruined his birthday dinner and want to make everything about me, but I just want respect.”

Reddit users weighed in on the MIL’s behavior amid more than 300 comments.

One commenter supported the OP, writing, “Your MIL is disrespectful given the context of her past actions. You’re not wrong to want respect as a mother and as your husband’s partner.

“Her trying to take your baby out of your arms without speaking to you, especially after badmouthing you publicly, was inappropriate.”

‘HUGE red flag’

Another supporter added, “There is no way I’d have let her take the baby… Ya done good, mama!”

Several users called out the OP’s husband, with one typical comment stating: “I hope your husband is defending you and not just letting this go on.

“If he’s just allowing it to happen then that’s a HUGE red flag.”

Conflicts between in-laws, particularly regarding parenting and financial boundaries, are common sources of marital strain.

According to Newsweek, experts note that tensions often arise when extended family members struggle to respect the autonomy of a married couple’s decisions.

Such situations can become even more complicated when money is involved, as financial dependencies may create additional expectations or obligations.

The Everymom raises the importance of direct communication and enforcing limits to prevent conflicts from escalating. Experts recommend that spouses present a united front and establish mutual boundaries to protect their relationship from outside pressures.

‘Bad guy?’

Speaking of a united front, the OP responded in the thread to the criticism against her husband.

“I think he’s trying to defend me, but it’s like he can’t stand up to them really, so I have to try to do it for him/us and it makes me look like the bad guy?”

Newsweek has contacted One-Pineapple6919 for comment via Reddit.

Newsweek‘s “What Should I Do?” offers expert advice to readers. If you have a personal dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice on relationships, family, friends, money and work, and your story could be featured on WSID at Newsweek.

To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, click here.